Hospital in Montreuil under scrutiny as nurse and former partner implicated in incidents of child abuse against infants, both currently released pending further investigation
In a controversial decision that has sparked public outcry, Juliette S., a nurse, and Redouane E., her former lover, have been placed under judicial supervision following charges of sexual assault on infants, possession and transmission of child pornography, and complicity in assault.
The investigation, which began after video evidence of abuse was discovered in Montreuil Hospital's neonatal department, has been ongoing since the case was brought to light. Despite calls for provisional detention from the public and Minister of Justice, Gérald Darmanin, the court has chosen to maintain judicial supervision for both individuals.
The decision to release the suspects under judicial supervision, rather than provisional detention, was likely based on the court's assessment of risks such as flight, reoffending, or obstruction of justice. The strict judicial supervision measures imposed on Juliette S. and Redouane E. include prohibitions on communicating with each other, leaving the Seine-Saint-Denis area, and engaging in any professional activity involving minors.
The court's decision to opt for judicial supervision over provisional detention is not uncommon. It is often chosen if the risks associated with the case are deemed manageable by restrictions rather than detention.
The public's opinion on the case is divided, with some expressing concern over the suspects' release while others argue for the respect of legal procedures for pretrial measures. Several experts have reminded that freedom is the principle and that provisional detention is only applied in cases of strict necessity.
Juliette S., the nurse under investigation, was confirmed under judicial control by the Paris Court of Appeal on August 14. The decision to release her was made despite the nature of the crimes committed. The Bobigny prosecutor's office has appealed the decision.
Meanwhile, the case of sexual violence on infants in Montreuil started on social media, fueling rumors and desires for revenge. A nursery school assistant is under investigation for raping and sexually assaulting children aged 3 to 4. The investigation was initiated due to an investigation by a whistleblower and an association fighting against pedocriminality.
The assistant, who was released on August 14, has been granted an appeal to be held in provisional detention. The case serves as a reminder of the complexities involved in the justice system, balancing the need for public safety with the principles of freedom and due process.
Redouane E., suspected of instigating these abuses, also had his judicial control confirmed. The Minister of Justice, Gérald Darmanin, has criticized the decision, stating that it does not allow for the detention of individuals who commit acts that deeply shock the French and endanger children.
As the investigation continues, the public will be closely watching the developments in this sensitive case. The safety of those involved and the prevention of further crimes remain top priorities.
- The court's decision to place Juliette S., a nurse under investigation for sexual assault and child pornography, under judicial supervision rather than provisional detention sparked debate over the balance between public safety and respect for legal procedures in the case of uncommon crimes.
- Redouane E., suspected of instigating the abuses in the Montreuil Hospital's neonatal department, was also placed under judicial supervision, which has been criticized by the Minister of Justice, Gérald Darmanin, due to the nature of the crimes committed and the safety of children at stake.
- A nursery school assistant, under investigation for raping and sexually assaulting children, was released on judicial supervision but has since appealed for provisional detention, highlighting the complexities of the justice system in handling cases of child sexual violence and the principles of freedom and due process.
